Make an Enquiry
Contact Us

Munby calls for amalgamation of youth and family courts

A ‘problem-solving court’ that looks at the difficulties facing both children and families should be introduced, a senior judge has said.

President of the High Court's Family Division, Sir James Munby, told the Howard League for Penal Reform’s 2017 Parmoor lecture that a re-vamped family court with an enhanced jurisdiction could tackle the problems a family faces as a whole.

“I believe that this points the way forward to what in my view is so urgently required: a fundamental re-balancing of the family court towards what ought to be its true role as a problem-solving court, engaging the therapeutic and other support systems that so many children and parents need,” said Munby.

“But the concept of the problem-solving court surely has to extend far further than that, not least, it might be thought into the processes of the criminal courts as they impinge on families, whether the child or the parent,” he added.

Sir James Munby highlighted the seven problems he believes need to be addressed.

  1. Cases involving children are spread across jurisdictions: the Family Court, the Youth or Crown Court, the First-tier and Upper Tribunals of the Immigration and Asylum Chamber and the Health, Education and Social Care Chamber. However, there are no mechanisms to facilitate collaborative, joint or even joined-up decision-making.
  2. Judicial decision-making is constrained by the extent of the resources made available by other public bodies.
  3. The way in which public finances are organised means responsibility is spread across too many agencies and too many budgets
  4. There is a lack of resources, particularly in a climate of austerity.
  5. Different government departments are responsible for various issues relating to children and families.
  6. The United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child has not been incorporated as such into domestic law.
  7. Too often with the criminal and family court, too much of the time and the exercise is still limited to determining what is the appropriate disposal for the case.

“In an ideal world we would be giving very serious consideration to sweeping jurisdictional changes, bringing order to disorder by incorporating many if not all of these jurisdictions within the expanded jurisdiction of a family court,” said Munby.

However, he said more could be done immediately including:

  • Improving understanding across the jurisdictions of how the others work.
  • Introducing mechanisms to facilitate collaborative, joined-up or even joint decision-making.
  • In particular, ensuring by appropriate judicial ‘ticketing’ and ‘cross-deployment’ that judges with expertise and experience in the family court can also sit in the Youth Court, the Immigration and Asylum Chamber and the Health, Education and Social Care Chamber.
  • In cases where there are parallel proceedings in different courts involving the same child, listing the cases simultaneously before suitably ‘cross-ticketed’ judges.

Munby concluded by calling for more to be done to embed Articles 3 and 12 of the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child and Article 8 of the European Convention in law and in practice across all the jurisdictions which impact on children and their problems.

Working Together For Children

Make an enquiry

A multi-disciplinary organisation providing independent, high quality social work, psychological, psychiatric, therapeutic and family support services. Contact us with your requirements and speak to a member of our team who will help you today.
Make an Enquiry

Children First

Sign up to receive our free monthly online resource covering the latest news and developments in the children’s services sector
Children First

Knowledge & Resources

Keep abreast of the latest news in the children's services sector.

A look back at 2022 with WillisPalmer's Head of Practice, Lucy Hopkins…

09/12/2022

2022 saw people trying to get back to some degree of normality following the Covid-19 lockdowns, restrictions and school closures that we had faced for the previous two years. However, the impact of Covid-19 continued and many services experienced, and continue to experience, backlogs and difficulties, including those services relating to children and families.

Social worker [...]
Read Full Story

John Lewis Christmas advert highlights important messages regarding foster care and looked after children

09/12/2022

Every year people are excited to see what the theme of the John Lewis & Partners Christmas advert will be. This year's advert reminded our Head of Practice, Lucy Hopkins, of all the times she arrived at the homes of foster carers with children or young people who were anxious, scared, worried and hungry, having just [...]

Read Full Story

The WillisPalmer Christmas Tree Decorating Competition 2022

09/12/2022
Who Wins..? You Decide!

We have two Christmas trees at the WillisPalmer office and this year the staff upstairs are going to compete with the staff downstairs to see who has the best decorated tree... and we want YOU to decide on the winner!

Tree 1 - Downstairs 

Tree [...]

Read Full Story
Children First is an online resource for professionals working with children presented by WillisPalmer, providing you with the latest news, features and interviews.
Subscribe Today

A Mackman Group collaboration - market research by Mackman Research | website design by Mackman

linkedin facebook pinterest youtube rss twitter instagram facebook-blank rss-blank linkedin-blank pinterest youtube twitter instagram